Compare and contrast maslows hierarchy of needs with herzbergs twofactor theory of motivation motivation is an intangible human asset which acts as a driver that pushes humans to be willing to perform certain actions. At other tomes, your social needs may be unfulfilled. The content theories mainly imply that individuals are unique and may have unique sources of motivation. Maslows idea that people are motivated by satisfying lowerlevel needs such as food, water, shelter, and security, before they can move on to being motivated by higherlevel needs such as self actualization, is the most wellknown motivation theory in the world. Compare and contrast of motivational theories research. The distinction between content and process theories. Describe its background, list its characteristics, and identify the problems with bureaucracies. Content theories address what factors motivate people whereas the process theories address how the people are motivated.
Furthermore, both theories are categorized as content theories which are. Compare and contrast the need theories and the process. Your motivation to write will become stronger if you are excited about the topic. The aim of this paper is to compare and contrast the theories of motivation. Get an answer for compare and contrast three motivation theories. Needs are deficiencies that energize or trigger behaviors to satisfy those needs. Learn vocabulary, terms, and more with flashcards, games, and other study tools. They are the process theories and content theories. Theories have been developed over the years as to what motivates us and those theories are what i intend to discuss. In a historical perspective, the content theories tend to be the earliest theories of motivation or later modifications of early theories. Compare and contrast two leadership theories essay example. But motivation that comes from within really makes the difference. Classical motivation theories similarities and differences between them stefanie hoffmann bachelor thesis psychology work, business, organisational and economic psychology publish your bachelors or masters thesis, dissertation, term paper or essay.
The rest differences maslows, alderfers, mcclellands, and herzbergs theories focused on satisfying needs but the goal setting theory focused on creating a need and reaching. Abraham maslows hierarchy of needs and fredrick herzbergs two factor theory. Compare and contrast the content theories of motivation. These theories look for the factors inside people that cause, sustain or stop behavior. Sometimes financial rewards motivate people and sometimes it is just an inner drive to make a difference. Goal internalization theories an individual adopts an attitude or behavior because it is. Comparing maslow, alderfer, and mcclelland most theories of motivation revolve around the idea an employees needs influence their motivation. Motivation according to vroom 1964 is based within the individual, which influences one to complete a task. The sum total of motivation theories can be broadly classified into two main categories. Difference between content theory and process theory. Compare and contrast content and process theories of motivation.
Compare and contrast maslows theory of needs with vrooms. Most research has focused on pay, but employees seem to look for equity in the distribution of other. The essay sample on compare and contrast the content theories of motivation dwells on its problems, providing shortened but comprehensive overview of basic facts and arguments related to it. Some theories approach motivation as coming from within a person drive theory, whereas other theories approach motivation as coming from within the person incentive theory. Compare and contrast two theories of motivation term paper. Compare and contrast of motivational theories writework.
Motivation theories are classified as either content or process. The distinction between content and process theories of motivation. At some point in your life, you might have a strong need for food and shelter. Free essays on compare and contrast the content and process. In the field of organizational behavioral studies, there are two different categories called content theories also known as need theory and process theories. Motivation is a process that starts with a physiological or psychological need that.
Content and process theories of motivation youtube. Motivation is influenced significantly by others rewards as well as by ones own rewards. In contrast, he can exert a lot of effort and still not catch a fish. Similarities between all three all are theories of motivation outlines how to best understand and motivate employees. Content theories of motivation organizational behavior. Venugopalan maslows theory of motivation its relevance and application among. Compare and contrast one process theory of motivation with one. The sources of motivation can vary between individuals and not the same factor drives us all. There are many competing theories, which attempt to explain the nature of motivation. Similarities and differences between the theories of motivat. Theories of motivation and their application in organizations. Compare and contrast the content theories of motivation essay.
Content theories attempt to explain those specific things, which actually. Pdf scientific management theory vs human relation theory. Herzbergs two factor theory is a content theory, while vrooms expectancy theory is a process theory. Suggest how a team leader might use these theories to motivate their team. Pdf comparative analysis of motivation theories researchgate. Sep 19, 2018 the main difference between maslow and herzbergs theory of motivation lies in the basis. What is the difference between content and process theory. There is no universally accepted theory of motivation. Difference between maslow and herzbergs theories of motivation. What is the difference between the content and process. Content and process theories of motivation essay example. They all illustrate what employees generally need and want in order to achieve a better work environment high morale and productivity. According to this theory, individuals acquire three types of needs as a result of their life experiences. The theory focuses on the content of motivation in the shape of needs.
The stronger your needs, the more motivated you are to satisfy them. Using a range of theories from across the hr143 syllabus compare and contrast two organizations of your choice from either the public or private sectors. Theories of motivation comparison and analysis uk essays. Maslows theory is a general theory on motivation which expresses that the urge to satisfy needs is the principle variable in motivation. Comparing and contrasting abraham maslows hierarchy of needs and herzbergs. Start studying compare and contrast contemporary theories of motivation learn vocabulary, terms, and more with flashcards, games, and other study tools. The main difference between content and process theories is that content theory focuses on individual needs, while process theory focuses on behavior. These include the abraham maslow hierarchy of needs, frederick herzbergs motivation and hygiene factors etc. Compare and contrast the the cannonbard, jameslange, schachtersinger twofactor, and other theories of emotion as we move through our daily lives, we experience a variety of emotions. Compare and contrast one process theory of motivation with. Pdf comparing and contrasting abraham maslows hierarchy.
These theories are all, at least, partially true, and all help to explain the behavior of certain people at certain times. Compare and contrast two theories of motivation free essays. It is probably safe to say that the most wellknown theory of motivation is maslows need hierarchy theory maslows theory is based on the human needs. A comparison of two theories of learning behaviorism. The aim of the article is to compare motivation theories from the view of general. As youll see later in this chapter, we have since developed more valid explanations of motivation, but you should know these early theories for at least two reasons. Comparison of maslow and herzberg theory of motivation. Motivation is a well recognized concept in management and leadership practice of organisations. Jan 24, 2011 there are two types of theories concerning motivation of employees. Check out our top free essays on compare and contrast the content and process theories of motivation to help you write your own essay. Process theories place emphasis on the actual process of motivation.
Motivation theories help managers to understand the best approaches to use to. Most contemporary theories recognize that motivation begins with individual needs. This essay will compare and contrast two of the most influential theories of motivation to date. Quizlet flashcards, activities and games help you improve your grades. Content theories address what factors motivate people. In contrast, herzbergs theory on motivation reveals that there are a number of variables existing at the workplace that results in job satisfaction or dissatisfaction. Comparative analysis of motivation theories article pdf available in international journal of mathematical, engineering and management sciences 11.
The content and process theories of motivation provide human resource managers with the basic understanding of personal needs deficiencies, and how these needs can be transformed into motivated behavior. Compare and contrast two theories of motivation suggest how a team leader might use these theories to motivate their team. A cursory view of the literature will show that there are two central categories of motivation theories. It should be understood that the skilled human resource management involves an understanding of the managers along with the welldesigned organizational structure and coordination of workers and their effective work. Content theories of motivation principles of management.
Content theories suggest that everyone has the same set of needs and examines an employees requirements from a job looking at physical, social and. Similarities and differences between the theories of. This paper aims to compare the similarities and contrast the differences in the works of maslow and skinner that influence on behavior. Content theories attempt to explain those specific things, which actually motivate the individual at work. Compare and contrast two theories of motivation explaining how the two approaches may differ and how they may be similar. In this section, we will look at the four content theories of motivation that dominate organizational thinking today. So the key to writing a compare and contrast essay is learning to do the research and organizing the information. These different cognitive theories of motivation are usually divided into two contrasting approaches1.
Motivation among employees in organisations is a key managers function. Describe a content theory of motivation, and compare and contrast the main content theories of motivation. These theories are more concerned with how behavior is initiated, directed and sustained. Essay question compare and contrast two theories of motivation.
In contrast, there appears to be more number of cases that once universal and general. A close examination of herzbergs model indicates that for those employees who have achieved a level of social and economic progress in the society, higherlevel needs of maslows model esteem and selfactualization are the primary motivators. Pdf comparison of process theories to content theories in. Motivation within marks and spencer s marks and spencer s exercise a very effective motivational policy via their very successful human resources department. This essay will begin first of all by defining motivation as a business concept and then go on to present one process and content theory each before finally. A comparison of two theories of learning behaviorism and constructivism as applied to. Whereas a behaviorist would continue to look at the content to be learned and the influence of the environment upon that learning, a constructivist would be more interested in. Compare and contrast any two theories of leadership in the following essay i will look at leadership, its definition and compare and contrast two theories behind it. Motivation theories can be classified broadly into two different perspectives. Over the years, many psychologists have developed various theories of motivation based on what they believe motivates people and why different people react and behave differently in a range of situations. Content theories are centered on the assumption that individuals all share a similar set of human needs and those human beings are all motivated to. Herzbergs motivation hygiene theory twofactor theory frederick herzberg felt that job satisfaction and dissatisfaction do not exist on the same continuum, but on dual scales.
Compare and contrast maslows hierarchy of needs with. The distinction between content and process theories notesmatic. In other words, certain things, which herzberg called hygiene factors, could cause a person to become unhappy with their job. Content theory vs process theory difference between content theory and process theory is that, content theory emphasizes on the reasons for changing the human needs frequently while process theory focuses on the psychological processes which affect motivation, with regard to the expectations, goals, and perceptions of equity. To understand the content theory of motivation in relation to public speaking first understand the definition of motivation. This will consider the more prominent theory of motivation in the content category. Compare and contrast one process theory of motivation essay. What inspires employees to provide excellent service, market a companys products effectively, or achieve the goals set for them. Answering this question is of utmost importance if we are to understand and manage the work behavior of our peers, subordinates, and even supervisors. There is a great similarity between maslows and herzbergs models of motivation. Jul 09, 2017 the distinction between content and process theories of motivation motivation is generally understood as the drive or the desire to do things. In content theories of motivation, there are numerous definitions in explaining the meanings and sources of intrinsic and extrinsic motivation. Similarities of maslow and herzberg theory of motivation there is a great similarity between maslows and herzbergs models of motivation.
Jun 24, 2011 compare and contrast maslows theory of needs with vrooms expectancy theory compare and contrast maslows theory of needs with vrooms expectancy theory motivation is an intangible human asset which acts as a driver that pushes humans to be willing to perform certain actions. Similarities of maslow and herzberg theory of motivation. The aim of this paper is to compare and contrast the theories of motivation and how they are used to inspire employees to develop the drive to achieve. We have appreciated earlier the importance of motivation in determining human behaviour. Motivation, a noun, is the reasons for acting or behaving in a particular way. Start studying compare and contrast early theories of motivation. Goal setting theory differences how will this content help me in the future. Process theories attempt to identify the relationship among the dynamic variables, which make up motivation.
An emotion is a subjective state of being that we often describe as our feelings. Quit chapter start contents video chapter end web site. Motivation theories instrumental theoriesthe individual engages in the behavior because she believes it will lead to certain outcome intrinsic theories the individual engages in the behavior because it is fun. Needs are physiological or psychological scarcities that stimulate behavior therefore are necessary to live a healthy, productive lives both in personal and work lives. Among the needbased approaches to motivation, douglas mcclellands acquired needs theory is the one that has received the greatest amount of support. Compare and contrast one process theory of motivation with one content theory. Theories of motivation an attempt is made in this chapter to bring a theoretical base for motivation.
As is common in any attempt to compare and contrast similar products, processes, or ideas, di. Content theories deal with what motivates people and it is concerned with. I will firstly see if there is a distinction between leadership and management as suggested by john kotter1990 who goes on further to stress that organisations require both a. Compare and contrast herzbergs two factor theory with vroom.
Within the work environment they have had the greatest impact on management practice and policy, whilst within academic circles they are the least accepted. The main difference between maslow and herzbergs theory of motivation lies in the basis. Chapter 5 contemporary theories of motivation integrating. Also, it is a general desire or willingness of someone to do something.
Three content theories of motivation and their comparisons. Different approaches applied by them have resulted in a number of theories concerning motivation. Include in your answer a brief explanation why one is a process and the other is a content theory. Content theories of motivation also referred to as needs theories focus on the needs that motivate behavior. This essay will then use these theories to explain how a team leader might use these to motivate their team members.
Explain the difference between content theories of motivation and process theories of motivation. Apply motivation theories to analyze performance problems. These two popular motivation theories are abraham maslows theory of motivation popularly known as the maslow need hierarchy theory and burrhus frederic skinners behaviorist theory green, 2002. Compare and contrast maslows theory of needs with vrooms expectancy theory compare and contrast maslows theory of needs with vrooms expectancy theory motivation is an intangible human asset which acts as a driver that pushes. Compare and contrast 3 motivational theories free essays. Content theories assume that everyone possesses a common set of needs and looks at what motivates people at work. Based on this approach, managers would benefit from understanding what people need so that the actions of employees can be understood and managed. Steers, 1996 one of the main differences between the two theories is that the equity theory is a process theory and the erg theory is a content theory. Oct 26, 2014 content theory vs process theory difference between content theory and process theory is that, content theory emphasizes on the reasons for changing the human needs frequently while process theory focuses on the psychological processes which affect motivation, with regard to the expectations, goals, and perceptions of equity. These theories provide insight into what motivates people to act a certain way in a particular setting and are popular in business management. Pdf motivation theories have been classified into process theory. Comparison between process theories and content theories is not. The aim of this paper is to compare and contrast the theories of motivation and how.
145 1493 70 1594 1583 412 1563 59 357 1603 1474 408 1502 156 472 468 649 485 516 269 1245 511 841 910 884 1354 811 949 852 440 1024 402 890 202 943 874